Which Supplements Are Helpful—and Which Are Harmful?
Search terms: best supplements for health, supplement side effects, do I need supplements
Supplements are everywhere—promising to boost your energy, support your immune system, help you sleep, or heal chronic illness. But not all supplements are created equal, and many people unknowingly take the wrong ones—or take too many—and end up making their health worse.
This page breaks down which supplements may support your healing—and which ones can cause harm—plus why it’s essential to work with a qualified clinical nutritionist for personalized guidance.
⚠️ The Risks of Self-Prescribing Supplements
Even “natural” supplements can:
-
Disrupt nutrient balance
-
Interfere with medications
-
Overstimulate the immune or nervous system
-
Cause liver or kidney stress
-
Lead to dependency or tolerance
“Supplements are not risk-free. Overuse, contamination, and nutrient imbalance are common causes of harm.”
(Cohen, 2014)
✅ Commonly Helpful Supplements (Under Clinical Supervision)
Supplement | Potential Benefits | Risks & Side Effects |
---|---|---|
Magnesium glycinate | Muscle relaxation, sleep, mood, blood pressure support | Loose stools (with high doses), low blood pressure in sensitive individuals |
Vitamin D3 + K2 | Immune support, bone health, inflammation control | Excess can raise calcium levels, causing fatigue, nausea, or kidney strain |
Omega-3 (Fish oil) | Brain, heart, and joint support; anti-inflammatory | May thin blood; avoid before surgery or with blood thinners |
Zinc (balanced with copper) | Immune health, skin, hormone balance | Too much can suppress copper and immunity; nausea on empty stomach |
B-Complex (methylated) | Energy production, detox, brain health (esp. B12, B6, folate) | Can overstimulate or cause anxiety in high doses; may worsen insomnia if taken at night |
Probiotics | Gut balance, digestion, immune function | May cause bloating or gas initially; harmful strains possible in some low-quality brands |
❌ Supplements to Avoid or Use With Caution
Supplement | Reason for Caution |
---|---|
Iron (unsupervised) | Easily toxic in high doses; can cause oxidative stress, constipation, or liver overload |
Calcium carbonate | Poorly absorbed and may calcify arteries, especially when taken with D3 |
Melatonin (daily use) | May reduce natural melatonin production over time; disrupts circadian rhythm |
Synthetic multivitamins | Often contain low-quality forms, dyes, and imbalanced ratios |
High-dose antioxidants (A, E, selenium) | In excess, may block beneficial stress signals needed for healing |
Green powders/detox blends | Often contain poorly studied herbs, fillers, or inflammatory binders |
“Unsupervised supplementation may lead to toxicity, organ stress, and micronutrient competition.”
(National Institutes of Health, 2021)
🌿 Why Supplements Alone Are Not the Answer
-
They cannot replace whole food nutrition
-
They can mask symptoms without treating root causes
-
They’re often based on trends—not science
-
Some interact with medications or conditions silently
🧠 Work With a Clinical Nutritionist
If you want to supplement safely, work with a clinical nutritionist or functional medicine provider. They can run labs to assess:
-
Vitamin and mineral deficiencies
-
Methylation and detox pathways
-
Hormone and gut imbalances
-
Inflammation and oxidative stress levels
⚠️ Never take supplements long-term without personalized testing or expert guidance.
You can get started by booking a free ASTR Diet health consultation here:
👉 Free Consultation With a Health Coach
🧬 The ASTR Diet: Nutrition First, Supplements Last
o ASTR Diet focuses on meeting your body’s needs through food—not pills. It emphasizes:
-
Nutrient-dense, anti-inflammatory meals
-
Gut healing and detox support
-
Strategic intermittent fasting
-
Clean, whole food-based nourishment
Supplements are used sparingly and only when necessary to correct deficiencies—guided by lab testing and clinical oversight.
👉 Learn more in the Eat to Heal book, where Dr. Joseph Jacobs shares how to nourish your body naturally.
📚 References
-
Cohen, P. A. (2014). Hazards of dietary supplements. New England Journal of Medicine, 370(14), 1277–1280.
-
National Institutes of Health. (2021). Dietary Supplement Fact Sheets. Office of Dietary Supplements.
-
Bjelakovic, G., et al. (2012). Antioxidant supplements for prevention of mortality in healthy participants and patients with various diseases. Banco de Dados Cochrane de Revisões Sistemáticas, (3).
-
Hathcock, J. N. (2014). Vitamins and minerals: Efficacy and safety. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 85(1), 280S–283S.
-
Dickinson, A., & MacKay, D. (2014). Health habits and other characteristics of dietary supplement users. Nutrition Journal, 13(1), 14.